All-Time AL/NL All-Star Team

Scott Seigel of Brooklyn assembled this gem.  He tells us, “This was inspired by Roberto Alomar's HOF election.  This team of All-Stars, represents those players that were at least five-time major league All-Stars, but were represented both the American League and National League teams.”

                                                                                        AL           NL

1b -       JOHNNY MIZE*                              7            1           Bio

2b -       ROBERTO ALOMAR*              11            1

3b -       GRAIG NETTLES                          5            1           Bio

SS -      GARY SHEFFIELD                        2            7

 C -       TED SIMMONS                              2            6

LF -       FRANK ROBINSON*                    6            8

CF -      DAVE WINFIELD*                        8            4           Bio

RF -      HANK AARON*                            1          23           Bio

DH -      EDDIE MURRAY*                        7            1

PH - (r)   MARK McGWIRE                          9            3

PH - (l)   JIM THOME                                   4            1

PH - (b) TONY FERNANDEZ                     4            1

PR -       KENNY LOFTON                          5            1

Pitching                                                         

RH -      NOLAN RYAN*                            6            2           Bio

RH -        GAYLORD PERRY*                      2            3           Bio

RH -        PEDRO MARTINEZ                       4            4

RH -      ROGER CLEMENS                        9            2

RH -      ROY HALLADAY                         6            2

LH -        RANDY JOHNSON                       5            5

LH -        VIDA BLUE                                   3            3

RP -        RICH GOSSAGE*                          6            3

RP -        ROLLIE FINGERS*                       6            1           Bio

RP -       DOUG JONES                                3            2

Closer - LEE SMITH                                    2            5

Mgr -     WILLIE RANDOLPH                     5            1

Reserves

KEVIN BROWN                                       1            5

JIM BUNNING*                                       5            2

MIGUEL CABRERA                                 1            4

LEO CARDENAS                                     1            4

DAVID CONE                                          2            3

NOMAR GARCIAPARRA                        5            1

DUTCH LEONARD                                  4            1

FRED McGRIFF                                        1            4

BOBBY MURCER                                    4            1   Bio

PAUL O'NEILL                                         4            1   Bio

LANCE PARRISH                                     7            1

COOKIE ROJAS                                       4            1

JOHN ROSEBORO                                   1            5

STEVE SAX                                              2            3

CURT SCHILLING                                   1            5

ALFONSO SORIANO                               4            3

RUSTY STAUB                                        1            5

MIGUEL TEJADA                                    4            2

JOHNNY TEMPLE                                   2            4

Key

*Hall of Fame

ALL CAPS = All-Star

Bold = Inspiration

Underlined = Negro Leagues